Villa Zorayda was built in 1883 by Franklin W. Smith as his winter home utilizing Moorish Revival Architecture. Smith was a wealthy hardware merchant and architect from Boston, Massachusetts who traveled the world extensively studying ancient civilizations, architecture, and construction methods. In America, he designed and built in different styles. He used his structures as educational tools to teach about past civilizations from around the world and he documented his research in his book, Design and Prospectus.
After 20 years as a residence, the Villa Zorayda was leased out and transformed into the Zorayda Club, a restaurant and club where the most prominent guests enjoyed dining, dancing, and socializing. In 1913, 2 years after Smith’s death, the building and part of Smith’s collection were sold to Abraham Mussallem, an immigrant from Lebanon, who was an authority on oriental rugs and Egyptian artifacts.
In the 1920s, the Zorayda Club became a gambling casino and speakeasy, and by the late 1920s, Abraham and his wife, Olga, decided to close the club and live in the building as their residence with their family. After a few years, the Mussallems realized how important the building was to St. Augustine’s history, and in 1933, they opened it as a museum, the Villa Zorayda Museum. The Mussallem family have now been the guardians of the Villa Zorayda for over 111 years. First, with Abraham & Olga Mussallem, who operated it as a museum until their deaths, and later in the 1960s by their sons, Eddy and Wally Mussallem, who restored the museum and renamed it Zorayda Castle. Zorayda Castle closed in the year 2000 and underwent an extensive 8 year restoration financed by Eddy Mussallem. Overseeing the restoration was Eddy’s daughter, Marcia Mussallem Byles, and her husband, James Byles. In 2008, the Villa Zorayda reopened once again as a museum going back to the original name given to it by Franklin Smith. Over 111 years and three generations, the Mussallem/Byles family have been the guardians of the Villa Zorayda.